Goodwill vs. Savers vs. Salvation Army: Which Is Best for Resellers?

If you're sourcing inventory for resale, you've probably shopped at all three of the big thrift chains: Goodwill, Savers (also called Value Village), and Salvation Army. They all sell secondhand goods. They all have that thrift store smell. But they are not the same — especially when it comes to reselling.

Let's compare them head-to-head so you know which one deserves the most space in your thrifting schedule.

Pricing

This is probably the biggest difference between the three, and it matters a lot when your profit depends on buy-low-sell-high.

Related: The Best Days to Go Thrifting (And When Stores Put Out New Inventory)

Goodwill:

• Pricing varies wildly by location. Some stores price everything flat ($4.99 for any shirt, $6.99 for pants). Others have started pricing by brand — meaning that Nike jacket might be $12.99 instead of $4.99.
• Many Goodwills now list higher-end items on their own auction site (shopgoodwill.com), which means the best stuff sometimes never makes it to the store floor.
• Overall: Low to moderate pricing.

Savers / Value Village:

Related: The Best Thrift Stores Near St. Louis for Clothing Resellers

• Savers tends to be the most expensive of the three. They price items individually based on brand and condition.
• You'll see more $7.99 to $14.99 price tags here than at Goodwill or Salvation Army.
• The tradeoff? The inventory quality is often better, and items are generally cleaner and in better shape.
• Overall: Moderate to high pricing.

Salvation Army:

• Usually the cheapest of the three chains. Many locations use flat pricing ($3.99 shirts, $5.99 jeans).
• They don't tend to price by brand, which means you can find hidden gems at rock-bottom prices.
• Overall: Low pricing.

Winner for pricing: Salvation Army. Lowest prices and the least brand-based pricing means the best margins for resellers.

Inventory Quality

Price doesn't matter if the inventory is junk. Here's how the quality stacks up.

Goodwill:

• Huge volume of donations, so there's a lot to sort through.
• Quality is hit or miss. You might find a cashmere sweater next to a stained Walmart tee.
• The bigger the store, the better your chances of finding good items.

Savers:

• Generally the best-curated inventory of the three. Items seem to go through more sorting before hitting the floor.
• You'll find more name brands and fewer damaged items.
• Great for clothing, shoes, and accessories specifically.

Salvation Army:

• Inventory quality varies a lot by neighborhood. Stores in wealthier areas tend to have much better donations.
• Less sorting means you might find great stuff mixed in with items that should have been tossed.
• Can be a treasure hunt — for better or worse.

Winner for inventory quality: Savers. More consistently good items on the floor, even if you pay a bit more for them.

Sales and Discount Days

This is where smart resellers save the most money.

Goodwill:

• Weekly rotating color tag sales (usually 50% off one color per week)
• Some locations run $1 color tag days
• Holiday sales (Memorial Day, Labor Day, etc.) often have storewide discounts

Savers:

• Super Savers Club loyalty program — free to join
• Members get 30% off during their birthday month
• Periodic 50% off storewide sales (usually a few times per year)
• Earn coupons based on how much you spend

Salvation Army:

• Weekly half-price color tag sales at most locations
• Some stores do 50% off everything on certain days (often Wednesdays)
• Seasonal "fill a bag" sales where you stuff a bag for a flat price — incredible for bulk buying

Winner for sales: Tie between Goodwill and Salvation Army. Both have frequent, deep discounts. Savers has good sales too, but they're less frequent.

Return Policies

Sometimes you buy something and realize it has a flaw you missed. Can you return it?

• Goodwill: Most locations do not accept returns. All sales final. Some may offer store credit within 7 days with a receipt.
• Savers: Generally allows returns within 14 days with a receipt for store credit. This is a nice safety net.
• Salvation Army: Policies vary, but most locations do not accept returns.

Winner for returns: Savers. Having a return policy — even just for store credit — is a real advantage.

Pros and Cons at a Glance

Goodwill

Pros:

• Stores everywhere — easy to find one nearby
• High volume of inventory
• Frequent color tag sales

Cons:

• Some locations now price by brand (less margin for resellers)
• Best items may go to online auctions instead of the store floor
• No returns at most locations

Savers / Value Village

Pros:

• Best overall inventory quality
• Loyalty program with real benefits
• Return policy for store credit

Cons:

• Highest prices of the three
• Fewer locations than Goodwill
• Sales are less frequent

Salvation Army

Pros:

• Lowest prices overall
• No brand-based pricing — great for hidden gems
• Amazing fill-a-bag sales

Cons:

• Inventory quality is the most inconsistent
• Stores can feel less organized
• No returns at most locations

The Verdict

There's no single "best" thrift store for resellers. The real answer is: use all three strategically.

• Go to Salvation Army when you want the best prices and the highest margins on your finds.
• Go to Savers when you want higher-quality inventory and don't mind paying a little more per item.
• Go to Goodwill for volume — they have the most locations and the most inventory to sort through.

The smartest resellers build a rotation. Maybe it's Salvation Army on Monday, Goodwill on Wednesday, and Savers on Friday. Find what works for your area and stick with it.

List Everything in One Place

No matter which store you source from, you'll want a fast way to get items listed across multiple platforms. List Perfectly lets you crosslist to eBay, Poshmark, Mercari, Depop, Facebook Marketplace, and more — all from a single listing. It saves a ton of time, especially when you come home from a thrift haul with 30 items to post.

You Might Also Like

• The Best Days to Go Thrifting (And When Stores Put Out New Inventory)
• The Best Thrift Stores Near St. Louis for Clothing Resellers
• Top 5 Thrift Stores in St. Charles, MO
• 10 Items You Should Always Buy at Thrift Stores (High Resale Value)

Use code THRIFT30 to save on your subscription. Once you're crosslisting, you'll see your sales pick up fast — because more platforms means more eyes on your items.